Making the call between repairing or replacing critical yacht parts can be tricky. Knowing when a component has reached its end-of-life and when replacing it is the safer, more cost-effective option protects your investment and keeps your yacht reliable on the water.

This guide breaks down typical replacement intervals, cost-benefit considerations, and clear indicators for common yacht components like marine impellers, anodes, batteries, through-hull fittings, seacocks, propellers, and engine parts. You’ll learn how to choose the right replacement parts and understand when professional installation becomes necessary.

Understanding Component Lifespans and Replacement Indicators

Every yacht component wears out on a different schedule depending on usage, environment, and maintenance. Below are typical lifespans and signs that replacement is the best choice over repair:

• Marine Impellers: Replace at 300 operating hours or annually. Cracked vanes, reduced water flow, or any dry run require immediate replacement.
• Anodes: Replace when 50% depleted to maintain corrosion protection; check quarterly in saltwater.
• Batteries: Lifespan varies by type (Lead-acid 3–5 years, AGM 4–7 years, Lithium up to 15+ years). Replace when capacity drops significantly or physical damage appears.
• Through-hull Fittings & Seacocks: Replace if cracked, corroded, leaking, or if installed components fail ABYC safety standards.
• Propellers: Replace when blades are severely bent, cracked, or missing significant metal. Minor damage may be repairable.
• Engine Components: Follow manufacturer guidelines; overhaul or replace based on compression tests, wear, and hours.

Knowing these thresholds helps prevent costly failures and unsafe conditions.

Decision Matrix: Repair vs. Replace

I put together this table reflecting common yacht parts, their expected lifespans, when a repair suffices, and when replacement is prudent:

Component	Typical Lifespan	Repair If…	Replace If…	Recommended Action
Marine Impeller	300 hrs or 1 year	Minor vane wear, no cracks	Missing/broken vanes or dry run	Replace promptly
Anodes	6–12 months (saltwater)	Surface wear < 50%	Depleted > 50%, chalky residue	Replace before next trip
Batteries	3–15 years (varies by type)	Loss of capacity reversible after charge	Swelling, leakage, dead cells	Replace fully
Through-Hulls/Seacocks	5–10 years	No leaks, smooth operation	Cracks, corrosion, leaking, ABYC non-compliant	Replace professionally
Propellers	5–15 years	Minor nicks or scratches	Bent blades, cracks, missing metal	Repair or replace as needed
Engine Parts	Manufacturer recommended	Minor serviceable wear	Compression loss, major damage	Follow professional advice

Selecting Genuine Replacement Parts

Using OEM or high-quality aftermarket parts is essential. Inferior parts risk poor fit, premature wear, or safety issues. For safety-critical items like seacocks and through-hulls, stick to certified components meeting ABYC or ISO marine standards.

When to DIY vs. Call a Pro

Routine replacements like impellers and anodes may be DIY-friendly if you have basic tools and knowledge. However, below-waterline components, engine overhauls, fuel systems, and complex electrical replacements usually demand professional skills to meet safety and warranty requirements.

FAQs

---

Making smart choices about repairing versus replacing major yacht components enhances safety, reliability, and long-term costs. Follow this boat repair or replace decision guide to plan maintenance effectively and sail with confidence.